• Skip to primary navigation
  • Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar
  • Inspiration
    • Beauty
    • Books
    • Fashion
    • Fitness
    • Movies
    • Mugs of Wisdom
    • Podcasts
    • Travel
      • Bainbridge Island
  • Food
    • Cooking
    • Entertaining
    • Our Wedding Cookbook
  • Community
    • Adulting
    • Gifts
    • Parenting
      • Country of the Week
    • Relationships
    • Traditions
  • Creative Life
    • Crafts & DIY
    • Knitting
    • Music
    • Writing
    • The Advent Box
    • Short Fiction
  • Home
    • Decorating
    • Organizing
    • Gardening
    • Lolligogin
    • Maryland
    • Washington, D.C.
    • The Southerner’s Handbook Adventures
  • Printables
  • Nav Widget Area

A Mom's Year

Creating a comfortable life one moment at a time

September 11, 2012

Homework: Good or Bad for Kids?

I recently caught a news headline that said that the Gaithersburg Elementary School in Maryland has abolished homework. Principal Stephanie Brant made the decision to eliminate traditional homework such as worksheets and instead have students read for at least 30 minutes every night.

I will admit that I’ve never been a big fan of homework. My kids are in school all day, so I’ve always thought of after-school time as family time. Or at least time to develop other skills and interests. Some nights the kids might be playing sports, going to dance or gymnastics, or practicing music. Or they might just be hanging out.

We do spend time going over spelling words, practicing multiplication tables, and doing the occasional worksheet that comes home. Now and then one of the kids has a special project to work on. But that’s about it. The kids have jobs to do around the house and we read together as a family every night. And that feels like quite enough.

Where do you stand on the homework debate? Do you think homework is necessary for kids to develop good study skills and get into top schools? Or do you think homework is more trouble than it’s worth?

P.S. If you think like I do, you’ll love the book The Blessing of a Skinned Knee by Wendy Mogel, Ph.D. If you don’t think like I do, I hope you’ll leave a comment anyway. It’s always good to look at something from all angles!

Also: The textbooks are from my days as an editor at EMC Publishing. I knew they’d come in useful some day!

Filed Under: Home Shannon 2 Comments

Reader Interactions

What’s the Greatest Halloween Costume You Ever Wore?
Color Me Rad

Comments

  1. Jonathan Wenger says

    September 11, 2012 at 10:09 am

    Seems to me that the idea has merit worth considering. It would need to be complemented by rethinking/delivering what goes on during the school day, since much instruction is built around the assumption that students’ learning is going to entail homework. School day/”classroom” time could be used more effectively by engaging students in dynamic/interactive learning activities as a rule rather than exception. But I do like the part about replacing “worksheet”-type homework with reading. Also like your point about the importance of non-school hours for enriching activities/family time/down-time. We want to cultivate integrated/balanced human beings, not another generation of depressed work-a-holics.

    Reply
  2. Steph says

    September 11, 2012 at 10:13 am

    I’m very proud of my namesake. I’ve always been against homework, especially for young kids. I don’t see the point or value of it. Children should do school stuff at school and home stuff at home. Reading is OK as a school-recommended activity, but that’s as far as I’d go. I got fed up back in Ireland trying to get tired, grumpy kids do homework that sometimes I couldn’t help them with (Irish language and even some of the maths). They hated me and I hated not being able to do proper mum things with them.

    Reply

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Primary Sidebar

Welcome

Hello! My name is Shannon Taylor and I’m a mom of four, originally from Minnesota and now living in Maryland. I "published" my first newsletter when I was nine, and since then, I’ve written and edited for magazines, websites, and textbooks. I started this blog when my kids were small to reflect on life, share ideas, and preserve memories. Now that my children are grown, I continue to use this space to document meaningful moments and practical ideas.

If you're in the mood for a bit of Christmas cheer, you might enjoy THE ADVENT BOX, available wherever books are sold. You can click on the cover below to learn more.

Instagram

Pandas are back at the National Zoo! We were there within days of hearing the news. 😂 Bao Li and Qing Bao are enjoying the spruced-up panda home on the zoo`s Asian Trail.

We last saw the pandas during a trip to D.C. in May 2011. I`m not sure if it was Mei Xiang or Tian Tian who firmly kept their back to us, but it was pretty hilarious. (photo #7) Not only did we get to see those wonderful pandas, but we got to spend time with Alexandra`s godmother, Amy, who was on home leave from her job with the State Department. Amy`s a fellow Midwesterner I met when we were interns waaay back in the day. (We connected watching "Northern Exposure" at Thompson-Markward Hall, affectionately known as the Home for Wayward Women.)

Be sure to put "Visit the Pandas" on your itinerary when you come stay with us in Baltimore. ❤️

10 0
Open post by shannontaylorwrites with ID 18295977556171943
Pandas are back at the National Zoo! We were there within days of hearing the news. 😂 Bao Li and Qing Bao are enjoying the spruced-up panda home on the zoo's Asian Trail. 

We last saw the pandas during a trip to D.C. in May 2011. I'm not sure if it was Mei Xiang or Tian Tian who firmly kept their back to us, but it was pretty hilarious. (photo #7) Not only did we get to see those wonderful pandas, but we got to spend time with Alexandra's godmother, Amy, who was on home leave from her job with the State Department. Amy's a fellow Midwesterner I met when we were interns waaay back in the day. (We connected watching "Northern Exposure" at Thompson-Markward Hall, affectionately known as the Home for Wayward Women.)

Be sure to put "Visit the Pandas" on your itinerary when you come stay with us in Baltimore. ❤️

My mom practiced, practiced, practiced and got to sing at Carnegie Hall for the premiere of "A Vision Unfolding" by Minnesota composer Kyle Pederson. A truly beautiful, uplifting work. I hadn`t been to Carnegie Hall before, so to visit for the first time to watch my mom perform was really wonderful.

Before the concert, we met Mom and her fellow choir member, Kathy, at Patsy`s, just down the block. The traditional Italian food was perfect on a chilly, rainy day—and it was fun to see photos of the celebrities who`ve dined there over the years, from Rihanna to Frank Sinatra (the restaurant`s claim to fame is that it was his favorite).

Mom, Tim, and Will hadn`t been to the 9/11 Memorial and Museum yet, so we headed to lower Manhattan after the concert. As we walked silently through the exhibits, trying to take it all in, I was struck by the distance between the concert, "A Vision of Light," and the grief and darkness around us. I thought of the words Mr. Pederson shared in the playbill, "It is my hope that we lean into the invitation that the choir offers—that each of us might reach out beyond our comfort zone and seek to build bridges of care and connection, finding a better way of being in community." And that’s what art does—it offers light when and where we need it most.

📷: Distinguished Concerts International New York

34 9
Open post by shannontaylorwrites with ID 18047049827096632
My mom practiced, practiced, practiced and got to sing at Carnegie Hall for the premiere of "A Vision Unfolding" by Minnesota composer Kyle Pederson. A truly beautiful, uplifting work. I hadn't been to Carnegie Hall before, so to visit for the first time to watch my mom perform was really wonderful.

Before the concert, we met Mom and her fellow choir member, Kathy, at Patsy's, just down the block. The traditional Italian food was perfect on a chilly, rainy day—and it was fun to see photos of the celebrities who've dined there over the years, from Rihanna to Frank Sinatra (the restaurant's claim to fame is that it was his favorite). 

Mom, Tim, and Will hadn't been to the 9/11 Memorial and Museum yet, so we headed to lower Manhattan after the concert. As we walked silently through the exhibits, trying to take it all in, I was struck by the distance between the concert, "A Vision of Light," and the grief and darkness around us. I thought of the words Mr. Pederson shared in the playbill, "It is my hope that we lean into the invitation that the choir offers—that each of us might reach out beyond our comfort zone and seek to build bridges of care and connection, finding a better way of being in community." And that’s what art does—it offers light when and where we need it most.

📷: Distinguished Concerts International New York

Is there a more endorphin-pumping experience than working out to `80s music? I don`t think so! Thank you to @natalie_dancebody and @mindi_dancebody for a truly joyful workout this morning. So much fun to dance along with two songs the Dancing Mamas tapped to back in the day at our kids` recitals: "Footloose" and "Beat It"! I hope you do this again, @dancebody ❤️🔥🎉

30 2
Open post by shannontaylorwrites with ID 18107239066486783
Is there a more endorphin-pumping experience than working out to '80s music? I don't think so! Thank you to @natalie_dancebody and @mindi_dancebody for a truly joyful workout this morning. So much fun to dance along with two songs the Dancing Mamas tapped to back in the day at our kids' recitals: "Footloose" and "Beat It"! I hope you do this again, @dancebody ❤️🔥🎉

Happy Valentine’s Day! I approach holiday greetings with more caution than I used to because I know these occasions can be painful for people who’ve lost someone. Which is pretty much everyone, especially when you get to be my age.

This day might not be the same as it was, but I hope you still have a valentine, whether it’s a romantic partner or a friend or a much-loved pet. Or yourself. We make good valentines because we know our favorite chocolate and what books we want.

I’ll always hang the Hearts on a String for any kid who’s home on Valentine’s Day, except not this year because the puppy would tear them to bits.

What a great Valentine’s message. 😅 Well. I do hope you have some treats today and you know I’m thinking of you fondly. ❤️

14 1
Open post by shannontaylorwrites with ID 18049981502173328
Happy Valentine’s Day! I approach holiday greetings with more caution than I used to because I know these occasions can be painful for people who’ve lost someone. Which is pretty much everyone, especially when you get to be my age. 

This day might not be the same as it was, but I hope you still have a valentine, whether it’s a romantic partner or a friend or a much-loved pet. Or yourself. We make good valentines because we know our favorite chocolate and what books we want.

I’ll always hang the Hearts on a String for any kid who’s home on Valentine’s Day, except not this year because the puppy would tear them to bits. 

What a great Valentine’s message. 😅 Well. I do hope you have some treats today and you know I’m thinking of you fondly. ❤️
Follow on Instagram

Fiction

Featured Posts

  • Printable Christmas Planner
  • Tim's Mocha-Almond Biscotti
  • Harry Potter Christmas Countdown Week 1
  • Kids' Craft: Smelly Christmas Ornaments
  • Gingerbread and Eggnog Trifle
  • Advent Reflections: Love
  • Advent Reflections: Delight
  • Heyday Farm Chocolate Pecan Pie
  • A Very Hygge New Year
  • Give: Ginger Soak

© 2025 Happy Crow Enterprises, LLC
About    Privacy Policy    Copyright
Pretty Happy WordPress Theme · By: Pretty Darn Cute Design